02.10.20

Murray, Murphy, Democrats Urge FDA to Immediately Ban the Use of Electrical Shock Devices on Children and Adults with Disabilities

After years of delay, Democratic senators call on the FDA to immediately take action to ban the use of electric shock devices on children and adults with disabilities

 

Until the FDA acts, the practice of using electrical shocks to punish children and adults with disabilities will still be allowed

 

Murray: “It is unconscionable that in 2020, it is still legal to shock children and adults with disabilities to control behavior.”

 

Washington, D.C. – Today, U.S. Senator Patty Murray (D-WA), ranking member of the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee, and Senator Murphy (D-CT), along with six Democratic senators, urged the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Commissioner Stephen M. Hahn to immediately ban the use of electrical stimulation devices (ESDs) on children and adults with disabilities. The FDA proposed a rule in 2016 to ban this practice. However, until the FDA finalizes this rule, ESDs—which attach to the skin and allow another person to administer electric shocks—will still be allowed to be used as a form of punishment and behavioral control. After years of delay and missed internal deadlines, the senators sent a letter urging the FDA to finalize the proposed rule immediately.

 

“It is unconscionable that in 2020, it is still legal to shock children and adults with disabilities as a method to control behavior. We have an obligation to protect children and adults with disabilities from archaic and inhumane forms of punishment—no more excuses, the FDA needs to finalize this rule immediately,” said Senator Murray.  

 

According to the proposed rule, electrical stimulation devices can cause psychological trauma and physical injury including “pain, burns, tissue damage, and errant shocks from device misapplication or failure.” The FDA has already determined that electric shocks pose a substantial risk of injury and that the “evidence is inadequate” to prove that these devices improve individuals’ underlying conditions or successfully reduce the targeted behavior long-term.

 

“That ESDs continue to be used on children and adults with disabilities as punishment is unacceptable. In one case, brought to light in an expose, a young man was shocked 31 times, ending up in a hospital due to the trauma and physical effects,’ wrote the senators. “This practice must be stopped without delay. We urge you to finalize the proposed rule and take immediate action to ban the electric shock of people with disabilities.”

 

The rule was first proposed on April 25, 2016. In the fall of 2018, and again in 2019, the FDA announced they intended to finalize the rule by December 2019. In their letter, the senators stressed that, “The FDA has missed its own deadline, allowing the continued use of electric shock on people with disabilities, including children.”  

 

In addition to Senators Murray and Murphy, the letter was signed by U.S. Senators Bob Casey (D-PA), Tim Kaine (D-VA), Maggie Hassan (D -NH), Doug Jones (D-AL), Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and Tina Smith (D-MN).

 

Full text of the letter below and HERE.

 

February 10, 2020

 

Dr. Stephen M. Hahn

Commissioner of Food and Drugs

Food and Drug Administration

10903 New Hampshire Ave

Silver Spring, MD 20993

 

Dear Commissioner Hahn:

 

We write to ask for immediate action to finalize the rule to ban the use of electrical stimulation devices on people with disabilities. Nearly four years ago, on April 25, 2016, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a proposed rule seeking to ban electrical stimulation devices (ESD) used for self-injurious or aggressive behavior.[1] The comment period for the proposed rule ended on July 25, 2016, with 1,209 comments. In the fall of 2018, the FDA announced[2] it intended to finalize the rule by December 2019. At the time of that announcement, former Commissioner Gottlieb stated, “We believe these products present an unreasonable and substantial risk to public health that cannot be corrected or eliminated through changes to the labeling.”[3] In the fall of 2019, the FDA again announced its intent to finalize the rule by December 2019.[4] Unfortunately, the FDA missed its deadline, allowing the continued use of electric shock on people with disabilities, including children. This is unacceptable.

 

The proposed rule would end a barbaric – and disproven - practice and prevent punishment using electric shock for self-injurious and aggressive behaviors. The specific devices the FDA has proposed banning use electrodes that attach to the skin and deliver electric shocks. According to the proposed rule, “the effects of the shock are both psychological (including suffering) and physical (including pain)”,[5] and the physical effects can be intensified based on the severity of the shock, which can be adjusted by a person other than the recipient of the shock. The recipient of the shock can experience trauma, especially with prolonged or frequent use of shock. In fact, the FDA determined ESDs used for self-injurious or aggressive behavior “present a number of psychological and physical risks: depression, fear, escape and avoidance behaviors, panic, aggression, substitution of other behaviors (e.g., freezing and catatonic sit-down), worsening of underlying symptoms (e.g., increased frequency or bursts of self-injury), pain, burns, tissue damage, and errant shocks from device misapplication or failure,” as well as “risks of posttraumatic stress or acute stress disorders, shock stress reaction, and learned helplessness.”[6]

 

After thorough review of the ESDs described in the proposed rule, the FDA determined these devices present an unreasonable and substantial risk of illness or injury, and a ban is appropriate. Indeed, the agency stated “the evidence is inadequate to establish that ESDs improve individuals’ underlying conditions or successfully condition individuals to reduce or cease the target behavior to achieve durable long-term reduction of the target behavior.”[7] Furthermore, it explained that state-of-the-art treatments for self-injurious and aggressive behaviors “are positive-based behavioral approaches along with pharmacotherapy, as appropriate, and do not include ESDs.”[8]

 

That ESDs continue to be used on children and adults with disabilities as punishment is unacceptable. In one case, brought to light in an expose, a young man was shocked 31 times, ending up in a hospital due to the trauma and physical effects.[9] This practice must be stopped without delay. We urge you to finalize the proposed rule and take immediate action to ban the electric shock of people with disabilities. Please provide an update on the agency’s progress toward finalizing the rule by no later than February 28, 2020. For additional information or questions, please contact Kimberly Knackstedt with the HELP Committee at Kimberly_Knackstedt@help.senate.gov.

 

Sincerely,

 

###



[1] 81 Fed. Reg. 24385 (Apr. 25, 2016) (Banned devices; Proposal to ban electrical stimulation devices used to treat self-injurious or aggressive behavior).

[2] Office of Management and Budget, FDA Unified Agenda of Regulatory and Deregulatory Actions (Fall 2018).

[3] FDA proposes ban on electrical stimulation devices intended to treat self-injurious or aggressive behavior, FDA News Release (Apr. 22, 2016).

[4] Office of Management and Budget, FDA Unified Agenda of Regulatory and Deregulatory Actions (Fall 2019).

[5] 81 Fed. Reg. at 24387.

[6] 81 Fed. Reg. at 24387.

[7] 81 Fed. Reg. at 24410.

[8] 81 Fed. Reg. at 24411.

[9] Jennifer Gonnerman, “31 Shocks Later,” New York Magazine (Aug. 31, 2012).